The option pool shuffle, explained
An investor asks for a bigger option pool, and asks that it be counted before their money goes in. The headline valuation does not move, but the price per share does. Here is who pays.
Worked example
A company has 9M founder shares and a 1M-share option pool, 10M fully diluted. A seed investor puts $2M into an $8M pre-money round and wants a 20% pool after the round. Same deal, with the top-up counted in the pre-money (the shuffle) and in the post-money.
| Pool target | Top-up counted in | Price per share | New pool shares | Founders | New investor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | Pre-money | $0.778 | 0.29M | 70.0% | 20.0% |
| 10% | Post-money | $0.800 | 0.28M | 70.4% | 19.6% |
| 15% | Pre-money | $0.722 | 1.08M | 65.0% | 20.0% |
| 15% | Post-money | $0.800 | 1.03M | 66.5% | 18.5% |
| 20% | Pre-money | $0.667 | 2.00M | 60.0% | 20.0% |
| 20% | Post-money | $0.800 | 1.88M | 62.6% | 17.4% |
The arithmetic at a 20% pool
- Pre-money (the shuffle): the investor will own $2M / $10M post-money = 20%, so the pool must reach 20% of the post-round shares. That takes 2M new pool shares. The $8M is spread over 10M + 2M = 12M shares: $0.667 a share. The investor buys 3M shares, for 15M in total. Founders hold 9M of 15M: 60.0%.
- Post-money: the price stays $8M / 10M = $0.80. The investor buys 2.5M shares, then 1.875M pool shares are added, 14.375M in total. Founders hold 9M of 14.375M: 62.6%, and the investor 17.4%.
- Difference: the shuffle costs founders 2.6 points here, and the investor lands on exactly 20%.
The headline pre-money is $8M, but the 2M new pool shares are worth $0.667 each, about $1.33M, so the existing holders are valued at about $6.67M. That is the effective pre-money.
Things to know
- The cost grows with the pool target. A small top-up barely moves the price. A large one, as in the 20% rows, takes a visible bite from the founders.
- An existing pool counts. Options already in the pool reduce the top-up. A pool already above the target needs none.
- Later rounds repeat it. Each priced round can reset the pool target, so the effect compounds across rounds.
Questions
- What is the option pool shuffle?
- The option pool shuffle is a term sheet convention where the new option pool needed after a round is counted in the pre-money valuation. The pool shares are created before the investor's price is set, so the price per share falls and only the existing holders are diluted by the top-up.
- How does the shuffle change the effective pre-money valuation?
- The headline pre-money is shared between the existing holders and the new pool. Subtracting the value of the new pool shares at the round price gives the effective pre-money for the existing holders, which is lower than the headline number whenever the pool is topped up.
- Does the investor pay for the pool top-up?
- When the top-up is counted in the pre-money, the investor owns exactly the raise divided by the post-money valuation and is not diluted by the pool. When the top-up is issued after the round, the investor is diluted along with everyone else.
- Can founders negotiate the option pool shuffle?
- Pool size and whether it sits in the pre-money or post-money are term sheet points, so they can be discussed. Founders often compare the size of the pool with a hiring plan for the next stretch so the pool is no larger than needed. This page does not state what is market.
Run your own terms
Change the cap table, raise, pre-money and pool target in the startup dilution calculator. It runs the same math as these figures.
Model the full deal in CapStackIllustrative model, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Real rounds also turn on SAFE conversion, anti-dilution and the exact pool definition in the term sheet.